Re: Seymour an Introduction

Could you point to specific examples of criticism by specific critics,
Paul?

Jim

Paul Miller wrote:

> Will wrote:I'll also point out that criticism is necessary when new
> forms or innovation in art appear (which is hopefully most of the time
> but not necessarily so...). For example, SAI was pretty strange when
> it appeared,...................... What I meant is that criticism has
> possibly missed the target with SaI by approaching it as another
> Salinger short story. Jim is correct we all do criticism in one way or
> another. Salinger is not painting with broad brush strokes, his focus
> is narrow and specific. I think in SaI he is about the work of Dr.
> Frankenstein or Gepetto in trying to make his characters dance off the
> page and greet you. Paul

-
* Unsubscribing? Mail majordomo@roughdraft.org with the message
* UNSUBSCRIBE BANANAFISH