I apologize if my reply is a little late and perhaps this point has already been mentioned since I've got loads of unread mail (most of which being from Bananafish) and am only up to Scottie Bowman's "a thought". But I resent that Vanity Fair as well as some people on this mailing list is comparing Salinger's (alleged) consensual, as well as legal relationship with an adult woman to Nabocov's character's raping of a minor. Completely different situations. Also, as I read Catcher In The Rye originally and the part where Holden is asking the cab driver where the ducks went in the winter, I was frusterated because I see the answer as obvious. Doesn't everyone learn in gradeschool that birds fly south for the winter? Love-Erinn