> So, did Shade grant Kimbote immortality, or vice versa? Or > could both be true, regardless of the "true" author? i think the latter is > true - mainly because Nabokov created both - like a set of mirrors directly > facing one another. A perfect analogy (: It certainly lends a whole new dimension to Flaubert's phrase - `The author must be like God in His universe; in everything but appearing nowhere'. For where can the author hide in this hall of mirrors? As soon as he believes he is concealed he catches sight of his arm or ear or mind .... > Take, for example, even the most trivial > example - something like Star Wars - does the entire "Star Wars > Universe" really come back to George Lucas? (God, I know I open myself > to ridicule with that one.) Not at all. I can see what you're getting at here, and it's a slightly different thing to what I meant. I've always condoned the idea that a novel or story or any piece of art is only a suggestion; a communication which is transformed and interpreted differently by each and every reader. Thus my Luke Skywalker is irrevocably different to yours. But it is interesting to speculate on the idea of whose name will live on longer - Luke Skywalkers or George Lucas'? And if the former is so, doesn't that mean the latter's does by proxy? Speaking of Flaubert (awhile back there) I've just been assigned `Flaubert's Parrot' by Julian Barnes to study in my Postmodernism course. I am quite amazed at the synchronicity it has with these things we've been talking about in regards to S:AI and Pale Fire. There's even a name for these texts in which one writer writes about another (fictional or real) - Metatexts. I highly recommend any Salingerian to give it a good look, because it encompasses a lot of the things we talk about in regards to Salinger - how much or little should a writer be separated from his or her text, the cult of the author, the death of the author, etc, etc ... Have any of you bananafishers ever read it? It was extra good to read straight after Seymour:An Introduction (I hadn't hunkered down with it for quite a while and doing so really opened my mind a lot and made things I didn't remember about it jump out at me) Camille verona_beach@geocities.com @ THE ARTS HOLE www.geocities.com/Hollywood/Theater/6442 THE INVERTED FOREST www.angelfire.com/pa/invertedforest