Thank you, Jim, for the explanation of 'cultural codes'. It sounds rather an arcane phrase to denote the difficulty we all have in entering someone else's world - a difficulty which increases, naturally, with the distance in time. When I write a book I try to offer a world for others to enter. That is my intention. And it's the worlds offered by Salinger or Henry James or Graham Greene that I try to enter when I open their books. I make the simple - but no doubt academically irrelevant - assumption that that was also *their* intention. What I find extraordinary is the general assumption throughout this discussion that Salinger in writing about New York in the late 40s is just about as accessible as some scribe from Ur of the Chaldees. For Cripe's sake, the man is still alive. (So far as we know.) Some of you younger girls shouldn't stop dreaming altogether of having an affair with him, even. We discussed something of the sort over a year ago when the topic of Hemingway's popularity came up. Matt Kozusko 'defended' the young of today by suggesting they would have great difficulty - & little interest - in relating to the Paris of the 20s, the scene of Hemingway's first great novel. I couldn't believe this. But perhaps it really is true that this generation of American 20 year olds is so blinkered in the present that they must be literary or historical scholars before they experience any curiosity about their parents' lives? When my grandfather taught me the more risque songs of Edwardian music hall or showed me photographs of himself driving the first motor car in the town, he wasn't trying to inculcate a sense of my English Heritage. We were simply having a laugh. Is American society so deracinated that no one nowadays talks to his Grandpa? The past was never so accessible. You don't have to be a musicologist of mid 20 Century studies to know Smoke Gets In Your Eyes. You need only turn the late night movie. When you watch a Woody Allen film, do you never wonder about the soundtrack tunes? What a bunch of dull dogs. No wonder you're all more at home with the metaphorical beads & flowers of the Glass family - while Holden remains a remote figure from a set book on a middle grade Eng. Lit. course. Scottie B.