Re: Mr. Antolini

Peggy F. Jean-Louis (pfj6868@is.nyu.edu)
Sat, 06 Dec 1997 14:08:48 -0500 (EST)

On Fri, 5 Dec 1997, Tim O'Connor wrote:

>I hope that this hasn't soured you, or anyone else who
> has remained silent, about this list.

Tim, thanks. No, I haven't been soured, it takes a lot to sour me, I'm
just passionate, esp. about the topics being discusssed.
This list does, however, seem to take getting used to. Things are so much
more laid back on the Seinfeld list :)

On Sat, 5 Dec 1997, Will Hochman wrote:

>Ignorance and vulgarity was offensive to the glass family
>I think those who attack criticism under the "amateur reader" banner are
>folks who think their readings are fine for them and that's enough--but
>then why bother with this list?

Ignorance? Vulgarity? I reiterate: "First of all, I certainly don't object
to people using literary criticism to discuss any author's work, including
Salinger's, in any way. In fact, I welcome it..."

Peggy