Matt's experience and mine seem quite similar (we even teach composition with guilt and awareness that our insitutions have built in "phoniness"!) in that we have become aware that many of lit's poets wrote crit and that some of our critics also have put their shoulders to the poetry grindstone. To be honest I don't dig genre for the divisions it creates. I think writers shoot out sparks and genre is about where they catch on best but not the burning itself. If anyone is curious I have a short (holdenesque?) essay hopefully playing with genre and baseball in ways that may amuse you and perhaps even in ways that echo some of Matt's fine thinking...("Beyond Exception: The Writers Life" in _The Salt River Review_, Vol. 1, No.1, Winter l997-98, http://www.mc.maricopa.edu/users/cervantes/SRR/hochman.html) will