Yes it was, and the sponsor, Mitchell Leaska was my teacher. When I produced "Slight Rebellion" in his point of view class (during a lecture on why Catcher was First Person) my academic carrer with Professor Leaska was terminated. I was shattered but picked up pieces and other Eng Ed folks helped me put my humpty dumpty phd back together again...will On Thu, 12 Nov 1998, Matt Kozusko wrote: > WILL HOCHMAN wrote: > > > There's actually an NYU dissertation on why catcher could only be written > > in first person...I don't accept the validity of this dissertation because > > the scholar had no knowledge of earlier "caulfield" stories written inthe > > third person. > > Very curious. I wonder how a PhD--especially at NYU--could manage to > overlook that early story, let alone be unaware of its existence. By > any chance, was it an English ed. student? > > > -- > Matt Kozusko mkozusko@parallel.park.uga.edu >