ars longa

Scottie Bowman (rbowman@indigo.ie)
Tue, 24 Nov 1998 08:15:00 +0000

    Surely the whole point of the Ern Malley episode was that 
    the critics who projected meanings onto the poems were seen 
    to be the idiots.  And, unless I'm mistaken, that was the joker's
    'intention' in the first place.

    They were fundamentally the same kind of idiots who hail 
    computer generated pictures or the daubs of chimpanzees 
    as works of art.  A landscape or a piquant human face may 
    arouse all kinds of emotions but they cannot be regarded 
    as pieces of art until an individual human mind has deliberately 
    worked to transform them into something else altogether. 

    That intended outcome by one man or woman is what 
    qualifies it to be even considered as an art work.  (And 
    don't talk to me about the moving effects achieved by 
    the commuinal improvisations of the local student theatre group.)

    Scottie B.