Posted by will hochman on September 17, 1998 at 00:06:12: After a long day teaching in Pueblo, I drove north to Denver to hear Ms. Joyce Maynard read at the Tattered Cover tonight. I let the long ride blend my memories of having last made this journey to hear Richard Ford read and how much I enjoyed his voice and story...and even to how I had done a reading at the Tattered Cover five years ago... I guess my timing back into the present was pretty decent. I had just enough time to grab some "cawfee" (I'm always a "new yawka" even when the yankees aren't winning!) and catch_Sabbath's Theater_ in the bargain bin for 5.98--and that's hardback first ed...but I'll get it on the way out, I thought, and only now as I'm trying to get rid of feeling tired enough to recollect that I realize it's really a book from an older, male view in ways that may or may not parallel her experiences with Mr. J.D. Salinger. The timing of my working my way through Denver's finest and largest bookstore to the third floor was synchronous with Ms. Maynard's arrival. We smiled at each other. I'm used to large eyes--my wife's are at least--and in some ways I quickly appreciated how easily the author smiled openly with her eyes leading the way. I took that as an omen to remove my lurking self from the last row and sit front row to focus my attention on the author. I'm a Salinger scholar who has no bone to pick with Ms. Maynard. That's why I'm commenting now though this isn't my first visit to this page. I'm glad to have met her and experienced with dimension what I had mostly read in the _Vanity Fair_ piece, the _NYTimes_ reviews, the _Time_ piece, the _NYTimes Magazine_ piece, the _New Yorker_ review and online. I may have spent a lot of time and effort studying Mr. Salinger' s fiction and the criticism that he generates, but I'm also a writer and respect Ms. Maynard's accomplishments as a writer. Hat's off to anyone who finishes a book! I'm a writing teacher and like to see words find good homes. But I had to wonder about Ms. Maynard complaining about all the advance publicity her book received...it seemed liked her publisher wanted to hype the book and she may not have been pleased with some of the spin on it... Ms. Maynard also mentioned at the beginning of her reading that she anticipated folks needing to vent and welcomed discussion from a variety of points of view...and then she read. I enjoyed her reading voice and watched her read to an audience while also noticing her seeming to scan us and read us. I took notes, and also let her reading tell the story of her relationship with "Jerry" Salinger, mostly just wanting information for my book, (in progress) _Salinger's Readers_(an ongoing process to rescue my dissertation from academese!). I was surprised by how familiar I was with every part Ms. Maynard read from _At Home in the World_. Either through excerpt or review, I wasn't learning more about Mr. Salinger, though I was pleased to learn more about the author in front of me and feel at home in her narrative about her realtionship to Mr. Salinger. When she completed her reading, despite her insistence on truth, I have to admit I wondered how honest she was...would Mr. Salinger really greet her in a bathrobe? She had descibed the expression I remember also seeing in a l989 NY Post Cover photo of Mr. Salinger...would he set himself for such pathos by wearing a bathrobe? I'm getting hung up on a detail, I think...as I also make myself clear about not wanting to get in a dog and cat fight but to learn as as I can with a public question or two. (But she does stress noticing small things and caring about them...) I tried to phrase my question softly, gently probing to find news of those Salinger manuscripts Ms. Maynard mentions in her book...unfortunately, Ms. Maynard took off on a straw man attack about how she was the subject of the book and she needed it clear how her need to tell this story is her story...I managed to reply explaining that her entire reading that night was about Salinger...but the dichotomy that surfaced most seemed to be who will you listen to--"The Great Writer" or "The Truth Woman"? I have to admit that I am not much of a reporter. My wife is one and I'm more of a poet (if you want the poet's "report," my latest are at http://members.spree.com/writer/) So I don't remember how I got more involved with Ms. Maynard's q&a, but I do remember her carping about Mr. Salinger not being fond of his readers. After Ms. Maynard trying make me a straw man/Salinger protector, I had to at least say he may not be kind to his readers in person, but it's on the page where his kindness matter most. I do love Mr. Salinger's writing--and I also love writing--and both make me know this screen or page is where I'm at. I think Ms. Maynard was gracious to me despite our clashing sensibilities and am grateful for the chance to really learn. Those who say she shouldn't write her words because of another author are denying what every author needs and each must give to help others...the spark, the ability, the magic of making words into lines on pages of a book. I wish I could have talked more with Ms. Maynard, which is what I'm doing here. I love the web and email, though at one point I think she believed I don't...ironic since I work hard at my school to deliver good electrons...you can even play in my web page http://www.uscolol.edu/english/faculty/hochman.html but the real point is that Ms. Maynard was apologetic enough for me so that after the reading and discussion she sort of let me corner her into visiting "bananafish," an email list concerned with Mr. Salinger and his fiction. I think it's wrong to corner anyone into a list, but just in case Ms. Maynard or anyone reading this is curious, TO JOIN ======= Send mail to: listproc@lists.nyu.edu Subject line can be left blank. (It will be ignored by listproc.) Body should have only one line, where FIRSTNAME LASTNAME = your name (e.g., Will Hochman): subscribe bananafish FIRSTNAME LASTNAME seeya there, will hochman