>Date: Thu, 06 Aug 1998 08:49:19 +0000 >From: Scottie Bowman <bowman@mail.indigo.ie> >To: bananafish@lists.nyu.edu >Subject: a watching brief >Message-ID: <0EX90074UCJMUC@acf3.nyu.edu> > > > Our own JD raises the suspicion - which has been mentioned=20 > on the list before - that the other JD, the Great JD, could himself=20 > be a member. > > To judge by the prim disapproval which has so swiftly met=20 > Joyce Maynard's revelations, the suspicion must be quite widespread.=20 > And the hushed, respectful tones which `mr. salinger' is referred=20 > to reminds me of nothing so much as the furtive nervousness with=20 > which the Catholic members of the class used to cross themselves=20 > when one of the naughty atheists stood up & challenged God to strike=20 > him down with lightning. =46inally. Thank you. I was beginning to despair that amongst the musings here, this list was really just pixellated genuflection. I sensed a little muted disapproval (between the lines) when I mentioned the angry pic a while back and while I don't suppose everyone here marches to the same tune, I worried that if I ever wanted to make my occasional voice heard, I'd have to be (over)careful not to diss the man. Obviously, I admire much of Salinger's work, but I draw a fairly heavy line these days at worrying overmuch about his sensibilities. --=20 Cheers, Andy