Our own JD raises the suspicion - which has been mentioned on the list before - that the other JD, the Great JD, could himself be a member. To judge by the prim disapproval which has so swiftly met Joyce Maynard's revelations, the suspicion must be quite widespread. And the hushed, respectful tones which `mr. salinger' is referred to reminds me of nothing so much as the furtive nervousness with which the Catholic members of the class used to cross themselves when one of the naughty atheists stood up & challenged God to strike him down with lightning. Scottie B.