Here's a little quote that may lend some insight to Salinger's feelings about professional literary criticism... "If there is an amateur reader still left in the world--or anybody who just reads and runs--I ask him or her, with untellable affection and gratitude, to split the dedication of this book four ways with my wife and children." >From the dedication to Raise High...and Seymour, An Introduction. To me, the bottom line with lit theory is that everyone, trained or not, who reads and talks about what they read is a critic. When you get so close to the work you can't talk about it you're closer to Salinger's ideal reader. But the minute you open your mouth, you replay the history of the development of literary theory Time and Time again... :) There's just no getting away from the questions asked and the answers explored whenever we read and interpret a work, then try to communicate that experience to others. That's what English majors do. Everyone who posts to this list is a literary critic, like it or not :) Jim