Jim - to answer these questions wouldn't Mattis (or anyone) have to go outside those same bounds that Mattis has in writing his `continuation'? Aren't you *really* just asking him to perpetuate his so called `wrong' Holden (I actually think you got him down pretty well, Mattis and still see no problem in the happy revelation of Holden's father. For - possibly - one day maybe he used to want to be a catcher too?) in doing so? This is a perfect illustration of the way everyone has their own perception of characters - and also have their own ways of filling in the gaps our author has left us. Thus - don't you think that `leaving' the world of the text has little other value than that of passing entertainment? This is exactly what the Fan Fiction I talked about is, admittedly - but I wouldn't propose it as the fodder of discussion. Just a thought, Camille verona_beach@geocities.com @ THE ARTS HOLE http://www.geocities.com/Hollywood/Theater/6442 @ THE INVERTED FOREST http://www.angelfire.com/pa/invertedforest > Kudos for creativity, Mattis, but I don't think that sounded like > Holden's Dad to me either :) Or Holden, for that matter :) I suppose > anyone can grow up, though, and it is interesting to consider what he may > have turned out to be...and even better, how he may have gotten there... > > Some FUQs... > > What would Holden have thought of Zen Buddhism? > > What would Phoebe and Jane have thought of each other? > > What did the shrinks and Holden's brother think about Holden's narrative? > > Write me a letter from Phoebe to Holden while he was in California, > during the time of > "his" writing of Catcher... > > Course, you have to absolutely leave the world of the text to think about > these questions, so.... > > Jim > > ___________________________________________________________________ > You don't need to buy Internet access to use free Internet e-mail. > Get completely free e-mail from Juno at http://www.juno.com/getjuno.html > or call Juno at (800) 654-JUNO [654-5866]