I thought about this a lot. Doesn't anyone like "Raise High the Roofbeam, Carpenters"? To me, it's always seemed the quintessential New York Salinger story; there's a wedding (sort of), the "uncomfortable in one's skin" sensation of being bound up, the August heat, Tom Collinses, drugstores, even a parade - and it introduces the fabulous "writing on the mirror device" (what's behind the glasses?). Plus, Muriel's uncle is so fantastic as a zen-like figure. Who could be depressed after reading this story? Give it to your friend. Let them read it in the bath. Lesley P. > ---------- > From: Ahimsa2000[SMTP:Ahimsa2000@aol.com] > Sent: Thursday, 5 March 1998 13:26 > To: bananafish@lists.nyu.edu > Subject: Re: just supposing... > > I think maybe I would get them 9 stories JUST BECAUSE there are 9 of > them (now > there's an egregious use of capitalization if ever there was one). but > what I > mean to say is, if, say, teddy is too depressing, they can always move > on to > pretty mouth and green my eyes, etc etc -- they can't all be > depressing. but i > can easily see how f&z could, since it's all so much of a piece. > > just a thought. > pauline >