David Straithairn as Nick Carraway Ashley Judd as Jordan Baker Chris Cooper as Tom Buchanon Renee Zewilligher as Daisy Vincent Dinofrio as Jay Gatsby I could almost imagine Tim Robbins playing Jay Gatsby(think about the Player) but he's too damn tall. Part of my problem with Redford is that he possesses too many physical gifts. I always saw Jay Gatsby as a small not too good looking man. For instance, I think I would have bought Dustin Hoffman playing the part. Directed by Julian Schnabel Best, Robert