Tim O'Connor wrote: > It sounds as if it's head-butting season in these parts again, > unfortunately. If it's all the same to you fellows, could you > take your spat to private mail and keep the personal attacks > there, not here? It's not really appropriate or pleasant to be > on the sidelines watching. Except that I'm enjoying it immensely. Would you mind cc-ing the exchange to me? For those who haven't stumbled on it one way or another yet, there is another account of Joyce Maynard's book--a review--in this week's _New Yorker_ (aug. 24 & 31). The reviewer is pro-Salinger, for the most part, but the excerpts he quotes manage to surpass the excerpts in _Vanity Fair_ in terms of scurrilousness. -- Matt Kozusko mkozusko@parallel.park.uga.edu